renzume.
2024-09-04

aposd-vs-clean-code/README.md at main ยท johnousterhout/aposd-vs-clean-code

A detailed discussion between Robert Martin and John Ousterhout explores their differing views on software design principles, focusing on method length, comments, and Test-Driven Development (TDD). While they agree on fundamental goals like code readability and maintainability, they disagree significantly on implementation approaches and best practices.

Original archive.is archive.ph web.archive.org

Log in to get one-click access to archived versions of this article.

read comments on news aggregators:

Related articles

Naming sum types is often hard

A discussion on the challenges of naming enumeration types in software design, highlighting the difficulty in finding unbiased and precise terminology that accurately represents binary states or conditions. The problem extends beyond simple true/false scenarios into more complex domain-specific naming conventions.

Postmortem: The singular design of Namco's Katamari Damacy (2004)

A detailed postmortem of Katamari Damacy's development reveals how this unique game, built around the simple concept of rolling objects into an ever-growing ball, challenged gaming conventions and achieved global success. The creator's vision focused on originality, simplicity, and peaceful gameplay, deliberately avoiding common gaming tropes like power-ups and complex controls.

the sudoku affair

A comparative analysis of two different approaches to building a Sudoku solver highlights how Peter Norvig's constraint propagation solution proved more effective than Ron Jeffries' incremental design approach. The core difference lay in their data representations - Norvig used a map of possible moves while Jeffries used a list mimicking the visual board, demonstrating how fundamental design choices impact solution elegance and extensibility.